Why Your Social Media Followers Aren’t Turning Into Podcast Listeners—And How You Can Fix It

3 Oct

TL;DR If your social media followers aren’t turning into podcast listeners, it could be because:

❎ You’re posting poor quality or mismatched content

❎ Lack of episode promotion

❎ Unclear listener benefits

❎ Inconsistent posting of your podcast and to social media

❎ Weak calls to action

Hey there! Just so you know, some links featured on this website contain affiliate links. So, when you click on those links and make a purchase, we may earn a commission. But hey, don't worry! It doesn't cost you extra, and we only recommend products we truly believe in!

So you want more podcast listeners

You’ve been working hard to grow your social media following, posting regularly, and engaging with your audience—but when it comes to converting those followers into podcast listeners, things just aren’t clicking - what gives?

If this is you, you’re not alone. So many podcasters struggle with this exact challenge. The good news is that it’s fixable! In this post, we’ll dig into some of the most common reasons why your followers might not be hitting that play button—and how to fix it!

Mismatched or Poor Quality Content

If your social media content doesn’t align with your podcast, you’re going to have a hard time converting followers into listeners. For example, if your podcast is all about finance tips but your social media is full of random (and irrelevant) memes, your audience won’t have single clue of what to expect from your episodes.

How to Fix It:
Your social media should give followers a taste of your podcast. Share content that reflects your podcast’s style, tone, and value. You can use episode clips, highlight key takeaways, and share quotes that showcase what makes your show unique. And of course, make sure that the quality of your posts—whether it’s visuals, audio, or text—matches the quality of your podcast. If you’re putting out low-effort posts, it could give potential listeners the wrong impression about your content as a whole.

Lack of Promotion

You’d be surprised how many podcasters forget to actually promote their podcast on social media. Sure, maybe you drop a “New Episode!” post every now and then, but are you actively making it easy for your followers to find and listen to your show? A lot of podcasters assume people will just know how to tune in, but here’s the truth: unless you’re guiding them, they probably won’t take the extra step on their own.

How to Fix It:
Make your podcast promotion a regular part of your social media strategy. Share episode teasers, behind-the-scenes snippets, and engaging clips. Don’t be afraid to remind your followers of where they can listen and also why they should listen (more on this below). A great Instagram feature to help with this is to pin a post with your podcast detail at the top of your profile or use tools like highlights to keep your episodes easy to find!

No Incentive or Benefit

Here’s the thing: people are more likely to listen to your podcast when they know what’s in it for them. If your social media isn’t giving your followers a clear reason to become listeners, they’re probably not going to bother. Simply telling them to “listen to my podcast” isn’t enough. You need to communicate the value they’ll get from tuning in.

How to Fix It:
Make sure your posts clearly explain the benefits of listening to your podcast. Will they learn something new? Be entertained? Get inspired? Use your captions to highlight what makes your show worth their time. You could also add incentives like exclusive content, bonus episodes, or even contests for listeners to encourage people to check it out.

Imagine this: You see an ad for a pair of jeans and it says, “buy these jeans,” will you buy them? Probably not. But if the ad says, “these jeans are so good you won’t even remember you’re wearing them. Yes, they really are that comfortable,” you might actually click to find out more! Get it?

Inconsistent Posting

Consistency is key when it comes to both podcasting and social media. If your posting schedule is all over the place, your audience might lose interest or forget about your show altogether. Plus, inconsistent posting can make it harder for your followers to trust that your podcast will deliver regular, reliable content.

How to Fix It:
Create a content calendar for both your podcast and your social media posts. This ensures that you’re consistently showing up in your followers’ feeds and reminding them about your show. Stick to a schedule that works for you—whether it’s posting daily or a few times a week—and make sure to regularly remind your followers about new episodes. Over time, this consistency builds trust, which can lead to more listeners.

Weak Call to Action

You might have great content, but if you’re not telling people exactly what to do next, so they might not take that step. A weak or non-existent call to action (CTA) is one of the most common reasons why social media followers don’t convert into podcast listeners. People need a little nudge!

How to Fix It:
Be direct with your CTAs. If you want your followers to listen to your podcast, tell them exactly what to do: “Click the link in bio to listen now,” or “Swipe up to hear the latest episode.” You can also add a sense of urgency, like “Don’t miss this episode!” or “Catch up before next week’s release.” The clearer and more compelling your CTA, the better your chances of converting followers into listeners.

Wrapping it up

If you’re struggling to turn social media followers into podcast listeners, it’s probably not a question of whether your podcast is good enough—it’s more about how you’re communicating its value and connecting with your audience. By making small adjustments to your social media content, posting strategy, and CTAs, you can start to see a real difference in your listener numbers.

Hey there 👋 Nice to virtually meet you! I’m Chelsea, social media and podcast enthusiast. I’d love to get to know you better, so here are a few ways we can stay connected:

🪩 If you’re a DIY type who wants to make the most of your social media, The Social Hive is for you

💌 If you want a weekly dose of social media tips & fun stories, then my newsletter is for you

📱 If you’re just hanging out on Instagram, you can find me at Honey Bee Social and The Social Hive